Colin F. Mitchell, BVM&S, Diplomate ACVS
Assistant Professor, Equine Surgery
LSU Equine Clinic, Equine Health Studies Program
School of Veterinary Medicine, Louisiana State University
Baton Rouge, LA 70803
www.LSUEquine.com
With the majority of lameness problems originating from below a horse’s fetlocks, care of the hoof capsule and its contents are recognized as a vital component of necessary care. Caring for your horse with the aid of a skilled farrier is essential to maintaining your horse’s soundness from birth to maturity. Veterinary input is often needed especially when lameness issues occur. To ensure successful treatment, it is important to localize the lameness to the foot. Your veterinarian can accomplish this by examining the horse, applying hoof testers and using nerve blocks. The results of this will help establish that the area of interest is in the lower limb. Radiographs can then be taken to examine the structures (particularly the bones) within the hoof capsule to identify any abnormalities. If soft tissue damage is also present, other diagnostic imaging techniques such as an MRI, CT or ultrasound exam may allow a diagnosis to be made. Having an accurate diagnosis will allow your horse to receive the correct treatment right away.
So whenever a problem is observed, a good working relationship between your farrier and your veterinarian will help achieve the best results for you and your horse!
Routine foot care is important, and starting this at an early age will help lay a strong foundation for future work and success. Starting early will help ensure your horse becomes accustomed to and comfortable with this “strange new” experience and facilitate proper development and growth of your horse’s feet, which will reduce the risk of problems in later life. Young horses often develop foot problems secondarily to rapid rates of growth, immaturity when born or because of pain elsewhere in their limbs.
Selective Problems in Foals
Flexor tendon laxity is a common problem in newborn foals and can occur in all breeds. The first sign of this is noted when the foal first stands and appears very loose in their fetlock, and if severe they can even be walking on the back of their pasterns. Fortunately, this is a problem that will often resolve rapidly as the foal gets a little stronger and older (sometimes even a day or two is all that is needed) and will not need any other care. However, help may be necessary for the foals that are walking or bearing weight on their pasterns. First, these foals should be confined to a well-bedded stall to reduce the risk of developing rub sores on the backside of their pasterns or fetlocks. Exercise is needed to allow the ligaments to strengthen, but excessive exercise will tire the foal and make the laxity worse. To prevent rub sores (foal skin is very thin and fragile) from becoming serious and the risk of penetrating joints or tendon sheathes, light bandages can be applied to protect the skin. Caution must be taken here as unlike adult horses, the muscles and tendons of foals will become more relaxed in response to tight leg wraps, which is counter productive in this situation. To increase the chance of success and the response time, some intervention by your farrier and veterinarian can be extremely beneficial. To help the foal develop a more upright conformation and keep the pastern(s) off the ground, applying a heel extension to the foot will substantially help. This can either be a glue-on shoe (sometimes difficult to keep on, even in young foals) or by applying multiple wooden tongue depressors (works best in light foals) with either tape or glue. This helps support the lax flexor tendons, and with a little care this problem can often be rapidly alleviated. Once the foal has a more normal conformation, both the mare and foal can have access to a paddock or other turnout as regular exercise is vital if the foal is going to develop healthy tendons, joints and bones.
Aside from being too lax, flexor tendons can also be seen to be too tight in horses. This is usually a problem of younger horses, and is more easily and successfully treated in neonates. Flexural deformities frequently affect the coffin (distal interphalangeal) and fetlock (metacarpo/tarso phalangeal) joints, or less frequently the carpus (knee). In all of these locations, the joint appears to be flexed more than normal, giving the appearance of either a very steep dorsal hoof wall, a fetlock that breaks forward or being over at the knees. These conditions can either be observed at birth (a congenital deformity) or as the foal grows and matures (an acquired deformity). If the deformity is congenital, early and appropriate conservative (non-surgical) therapy will often be all that is necessary to correct the deformity. Acquired deformities often occurs secondary to another problem, either because of pain originating elsewhere in the limb or because of rapid growth of the foal. For this reason, surgical intervention in addition to conservative therapy is often required as these cases are more complex and successfully treat.
Conservative therapy varies depending upon the location and the severity of the deformity. If the deformity is mild, often all that is needed is to ensure that the foal is exercising as this will help to stretch the tendons. Treatment with intravenous oxytetracycline (an antibiotic that binds calcium and promotes muscle relaxation) will often help relax the musculotendinous structures of the legs adequately to return them to normal. Applying “tight” bandages will also yield relaxation of the area that is wrapped, and this effect can be increased by adding a firm splint to the bandage to increase the degree of immobility from the bandage. These bandages should be changed daily and left off for a sufficiently long period to reassess the limb conformation and to determine if re-bandaging is necessary. Some degree of improvement should be observed within a few days.
If these initial conservative treatments are not enough to correct or achieve dramatic improvement, then applying a toe extension in deformities of the distal interphalangeal (coffin) joint can help stretch the tendons and allow them to assume a more normal position. Trimming the toe is contraindicated at this time, and it should be left in place and supported with a toe extension, either using a glue-on shoe or of hoof acrylic. This toe extension acts as a lever arm to force the heel down and stretch the deep digital flexor tendon.
Acquired deformities occur slightly later in life, usually after the foal is 3 months of age or older. By this time, conservative therapy with bandaging or oxytetracycline is less likely to be effective. To ensure the best outcome, veterinary intervention and care by a skilled farrier will achieve the best results. Restricting exercise and the foal’s ration can be beneficial when combined with appropriate hoof trimming, but if no improvement occurs within a few weeks, other treatments should be attempted. Depending on the location of the deformity, desmotomy (transection) of the inferior and/or superior check ligament(s) will help the tendons relax to allow more appropriate conformation. Special hoof care should also be combined with these surgeries, as well as identifying and addressing any other underlying causes. Toe extensions can help protect and normalize the angle of the hoof wall for flexural deformities of the distal interphalangeal joint. Care must be taken to provide protection to the toe, which is often worn short, to not remove excessive hoof from the heel region at any one trim. Changes should be gradual and low doses of phenylbutazone may be used initially to keep the foal comfortable.
Angular limb deformities are also often observed in young foals. These are often described as either valgus (the limb distally is angled outward) or varus (the limb distal to the joint is angled inward) deformities. Mild deformities in newborn foals will often resolve without any intervention, other than confining the foal to a small area until the soft tissues can increase their strength and support the region. When the deformity either is worsening or not improving after a few weeks, some simple care is often all that is needed. To treat a carpal valgus deformity, applying a dorsomedial toe extension is often beneficial because this helps turn the toe in slightly and improve the angulation of the leg. When trimming these feet, a small amount of extra hoof on the lateral aspect can be removed to achieve the same effect, but this can cause other problems if done excessively. We recommend the use of toe extensions and if necessary only one or two passes of the rasp on the outside of the foot every one or two weeks. Cautious trimming, applying extensions and restricting exercise are often all that is needed. Valgus deviations of the carpus are the most commonly seen, but if they remain untreated, the fetlock can begin to develop a varus deformity which can be harder to correct. In foals with deviations greater than 10˚ (radiographs are often needed and used to accurately identify the degree of deviation) surgical intervention is often used in conjunction with conservative therapy. Perisosteal elevation (to accelerate growth on one side), or in more severe cases, transphyseal bridging (to restrict growth on one side) can be used. Following any of these surgeries or corrective techniques, the foal should remain confined either to a stall or small paddock to prevent any exacerbation of the problem, until it has corrected. More severe deviations should be evaluated and addressed by a veterinarian before the foal gets too old. In general, foals with deviations of the fetlock should be examined within 2-4 weeks of age since most of the growth in the growth plate of the distal cannon bone has occurred by 3 months of age and for foals with carpal/tarsal (hock) deviations, the foal should be evaluated by 2 months of age since most of the growth in the distal growth plate of the radius/tibia has occurred by 4-6 months.
Selective Problems in Adult Horses
Adult horses often require special hoof care, especially to support and protect their feet during the athletic endeavors asked of them. Most if not all horse owners have at some time, heard or been associated with a horse diagnosed with navicular disease. This was a “catch all” diagnosis for problems thought to originate from the navicular bone itself or from the heel region of the foot, but with the increasing availability of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) technology (coming soon to LSU-SVM), diseases or injuries affecting other structures within the hoof, instead of the navicular bone (including ligaments, tendons and other soft tissues and bony structures) have been identified. This does help explain the reason for a poor response to treatment in the past when the lameness was treated more generically rather than tailoring the appropriate treatment based upon identification of a specific injury in each horse. The use of this advanced diagnostic imaging technology and appropriate corrective trimming and shoeing will help optimize the response to therapy, often without the need for surgeries such as palmar digital neurectomies.
Each horse needs to be evaluated on an individual basis so that it can be treated according to the diagnostic findings. Many horses with navicular disease (navicular syndrome, caudal heel pain) will benefit from careful trimming and shoeing. Any abnormalities of hoof balance need to be corrected, either mediolateral (side-to-side) or dorsopalmar (front-to-back), and additional support often needs to be provided to the heel region. Bar shoes (shoes that connect either straight across or in an oval shaped across the heels) can be applied in an attempt to protect and provide support to the heel region and spread the forces applied every time a horse bears weight to a larger area. Other horses, if they also have underrun heels or sometimes an abnormal hoof-pastern angle, will benefit from either a wedge pad to raise the heels and reduce the tension on the deep digital flexor tendon. Full pads can often be used if sensitivity is identified over the heel region until the horse can grow additional healthy hoof, but care needs to be taken as these can trap excess moisture underneath the pad. Using a rim pad will provide the same elevation, but leave the remainder of the sole open to the environment. The fact that each horse is different, and may even have very different conformation and shape to their front feet means that careful examination of each individual horse is necessary to identify the appropriate therapy; what will work for one horse is often contraindicated in another!
For best results, combination therapy is required. In horses with less severe lameness localized to the heel region, use of non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs such as phenylbutazone (Bute) or flunixin meglumine (Banamine) can help these horses continue to be comfortable. In acute episodes of pain or to maximize the response to corrective trimming and shoeing, injections of the distal interphalangeal joint or navicular bursa with joint medications (hyaluronic acid and/or corticosteroids) can be administered, allowing these horses to continue to perform.
Laminitis is often considered to be a career-ending if not life-threatening condition. Although much has been discovered about its causes and the most effective therapies, once the disease is present and radiographic changes have occurred, corrective trimming and shoeing is vital if the horse is going to become comfortable again. Two chronic forms or manifestations of the disease have been identified, rotation and sinking and these can occur separately or in combination. Rotation is seen when the laminae, which are the soft tissue attachments between the 3rd phalanx (coffin bone) and the hoof capsule break down and the bone rotates away from the dorsal hoof wall. Sinking occurs when the laminar attachments become so severely disrupted that the entire coffin bone drops within the hoof capsule, and is manifested radiographically by dropping of the extensor process of the 3rd phalanx below the coronary band; sinkage is a very serious change with an associated poor prognosis. Careful examination of these horses through a physical exam and radiographic examination of their feet is necessary. Whatever condition that caused the laminitis must be identified and treated to prevent further damage, otherwise corrective trimming and shoeing is unlikely to yield good results.
Depending on the degree of change observed radiographically and the comfort level of the horse, trimming and shoeing is usually delayed until the horse is past the acute stage of the disease and things have stablilized. Until this point is reached, the horse will benefit from the application of frog supports (polystyrene foam pads over entire solar surface of foot, custom-made frog supports, etc.) and the use of anti-inflammatory and analgesic (pain relievers) medication, including phenylbutazone. If rotation of the 3rd phalanx is severe, a deep digital flexor tenotomy may be recommended immediately prior to corrective shoeing. This surgery should not be performed without shoeing as the foot will lose caudal support unless it is protected with appropriate shoeing (often heel extensions are needed). The overall goal of shoeing in horses with rotation is to trim the foot and apply a shoe to reduce the deviation or at least reduce it significantly, while increasing the load bearing to other parts of the foot, such as the sole, frog and heels, all behind the apex of the 3rd phalanx. Ultimately, the goal is to “de-rotate” and allow the hoof wall to grow out parallel to the 3rd phalanx. Different shoes, techniques and materials have been used, but the overall goal remains the same. If evidence of sinking is observed, de-rotation of the 3rd phalanx is not always necessary, but the application of greater support to the sole region and heels is vital in an attempt to make the horse more comfortable. In cases with severe changes, the tip of the 3rd phalanx can sometimes penetrate the sole of the hoof. This is extremely painful for the horse and requires intensive wound management, to prevent the condition worsening, although this cannot always be prevented.
Unfortunately, no “silver bullet” has been found for treating laminitis, and corrective trimming and shoeing often must be continued until the foot has been able to recover and once again establish more normal laminar attachments. With the decreased rate of hoof growth that these horses display, this can often take nearly a year or longer. Trimming and shoeing is often needed (roughly every 6 weeks), thus dedication and adherence is required on the part of all involved, including the owner/caretaker, veterinarian and farrier. These cases can be extremely rewarding, especially when a horse that was presumed to be beyond saving makes a complete recovery.